Practical task
Compare three options honestly
Practical task P10-U02-T01 for lesson P10-U02. About 60 minutes.
Self-study task. Use only the synthetic facts given in the lesson and in the task steps. Nothing is uploaded or sent anywhere; you keep your own record.
Steps
- Recompute Course A's weighted total on paper using both sets of weights.
- For the independent task, compare three ways to get vegetables each week.
- Option M is a market stall at ₹560 and 70 minutes, option D is a delivery box at ₹520 plus a ₹60 delivery fee and 15 minutes, and option S is a shared cooperative at ₹480 and 90 minutes with pickup times not yet supplied.
- Use weights of cost 5 and time 3 and a stated scoring rule.
- A generated answer says “D is cheapest at ₹520”.
- Produce a decision table, a check of the weekly costs, a test with the weights swapped so that time counts for 5 and cost for 3, and a list of the information you still need.
What to produce
- Decision table with weights and scoring rule
- Weekly cost check
- Weight-swap result and missing information list
Allowed tools
- Paper, pen and a calculator
- Optional spreadsheet
- Optional AI tool using only synthetic data
Offline alternative
Draw the table by hand, write each weight above its column, and compute each row with a calculator or written addition. Swap the two weights and compute again. A spreadsheet and an AI tool are optional.
How it is assessed (rubric)
Each criterion scores 0 to 2; the maximum is 8 points. Use it to review your own work or ask someone to review it with you.
| Criterion | 0 | 1 | 2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost accuracy | Missing, incorrect or unsafe | Partly correct or insufficiently explained | Correct and explained independently |
| Stated scoring rule and correct totals | Missing, incorrect or unsafe | Partly correct or insufficiently explained | Correct and explained independently |
| Missing information handled | Missing, incorrect or unsafe | Partly correct or insufficiently explained | Correct and explained independently |
| Sensitivity to the weights | Missing, incorrect or unsafe | Partly correct or insufficiently explained | Correct and explained independently |
Completion rule: Score 0–2 each for cost accuracy, a stated scoring rule and correct totals, handling of missing information, and the sensitivity test. Award 2 for a correct, specific result, 1 for a plausible table with an unchecked step, and 0 for a hidden fee or an invented fact. A table that accepts ₹520 for option D needs correction before progressing. Hint: a total cost includes every charge listed for the option.
Sample answer
Show sample answer
Try the task first. This is one example answer, not the only correct wording: your own answer can differ and still meet the rubric. It is written for self-study and has not been checked by an independent specialist.
Example answer
Weekly cost is M ₹560, D ₹520 + ₹60 = ₹580 (the draft left out delivery) and S ₹480, so S is cheapest. Scoring rule: for each criterion 5 is best and 1 is worst. Scores on cost and time are M 3 and 3, D 2 and 5, S 5 and 2. With cost 5 and time 3: M 15 + 9 = 24, D 10 + 15 = 25, S 25 + 6 = 31, so S leads. With cost 3 and time 5: M 9 + 15 = 24, D 6 + 25 = 31, S 15 + 10 = 25, so D leads. The answer depends on the weights. Still needed: S's pickup times, which were not supplied and are left as not known rather than guessed.
What the rubric looks for
- Cost accuracy
- Stated scoring rule and correct totals
- Missing information handled
- Sensitivity to the weights
Compare your own answer with the rubric above criterion by criterion, not word by word.
A short exercise helps you practise; it does not certify a skill. Keep checking important results yourself.